| I
met Hibino Makoto in Minneapolis at the
8th International Conference on Bisexuality
last year. Expecting to meet people from
distant countries, coming from very different
cultural backgrounds, I saw a long-haired
person wearing a large pink skirt and a
hat. That was him. I thought "him"
after observing a while. But, anyway, who
cares? At this point I was just trying to
challenge my mental boundaries and find
interesting stories to tell.
Makoto San,
what would you say about the differences
and similarities between bisexuality in
Japan and in the so-called West?
I think that the special
features of us Japanese are that we do not
need to have strong bi identity like in
the Western GLBT movement. Not a small number
of people have bisexual behavior, and they
can live without coming out as bisexuals.
The first reason is
our historical and ethnic background. Before
Japan started to import Western/Christian
culture around 1867, it was common -- at
least for men -- to have sex with both male
and female, within both high- and low-class
society. As our country westernized, people
and our culture came to think of same-sex
relationships as abnormal.
The second reason is
the Tennou system (Japanese-style emperor)
that affects our daily life very much. This
is not only a political matter, but also
a kind of religion in our society. The Tennou
system means that people want to think as
if all Japanese are a family, customarily
tending to follow authority.
Here almost all queers
feel as if they were strangled with silk
floss, tormented at a low intensity. If
someone queer has enough pride and is strong
enough to come out publicly, then that person
becomes a kind of authority. But this is
very unusual. In contrast, there are people
who feel forced to kill themselves.
This is another reason
for not having any strong sexual identity,
even though bisexual behavior and so-called
"bi curiosity" is not so rare
in Japan now.
But we need to stand
up and say something. That is because the
imported gay and lesbian civil-rights movement
is trying to build a gay and lesbian identity
and pride, also bringing to us an acceptance
of the binary gender system of the Western
Christian culture. From these people's point
of view, bisexuality should be passed.
You mentioned
the cultural heritage of Japan, your historical
and ethnic background.
There are not enough
studies about women, but historically speaking
it was basically a normal behavior for Japanese
men to have sex with both men and women.
Maybe you know Ukiyoe -- Japanese traditional
drawings. There are many Ukiyoe which paint
men having sex with men.
Before around 1867,
it was well-known that many of the Syogun
(like a prime minister) had sex with both
male and female. Before Western Christians
criticized Japanese public baths, there
was a common culture of taking it with mixed-gender
people for the purpose of cleaning the body
and relaxing, not for sex.
In old days the temples
were very famous place where Buddhist monks,
mostly male, had sex with younger boys.
Around 1900, having
same-sex relationships became illegal in
Japan because of Western influence. That
broke the Japanese tradition.
I think that at least
in Japan and Thailand there is a long historical
and social culture of queer people and queer
community. There have always been spaces
within the society at large for gender queers.
Now we can find many queer people in the
mainstream TV programs, for instance.
We still have our own
unique traditional Japanese word -- okama
-- which means those who are out of the
binary gender system, including gay men,
bi men, MTF or MTX transgenders and others.
Okama, and onabe, is like the word queer.
|
 |
How
about the struggle for human rights of queers
in recent Japan?
There was a small group
named Occur that brought their case to court
in 1990. They made an application to stay
overnight at an educational institution,
but Tokyo's local government refused to
accept that because they were a gay and
lesbian group. Therefore, they went to court.
It was the first political
and public protest against homophobia in
modern Japan, and there were not many or
big movements yet at the time. There was
no parade, nor any demonstrations. But Occur
won the case, based on human rights. The
high court gave the same ruling in 1997,
and the Ministry of Education deleted the
description that officially said that same-sex
relationships were delinquency.
The Japanese government
proposed a law for human rights that prohibited
discrimination based on sexual orientation
in 2003. The law did not pass, but it was
proposed by the conservatives not by the
labor party or social democratic party.
The same sort of thing
happened with transgenders. Sex-reassignment
surgery (SRS) was illegal before 1998; therefore
many TS went to Thailand or the U.S. for
surgery, or underwent it underground.
In 1998, Dr. Harashina
decided to perform and announce a SRS officially
and publicly. Harashina introduced the concept
of Gender Identity Disorder, and no one
blamed him after that. Now SRS is a legal
treatment for transsexuals.
Also in 2003, a new
law for GID transsexuals to change their
gender on their legal papers passed easily
at the National Diet. It took only five
years from the first public SRS.
Speaking about
the B and T in GLBT, how has been the process
of having those letters put together?
Mainly, bisexuality
is cloaked in invisibility for the gay and
lesbian movement. For example, Occur, the
most famous gay and lesbian group in Japan,
does not have anything bi.
Anyway, there have been
many discussions, especially on women's
bisexuality, and now many places, movements
or weekend events are named "for lesbian
and bi women." But including the words
bisexual and transgender in the name of
a big event like a parade or film festival
means that we are forced to choose whether
to keep insisting on equal rights -- which
has a possibility to break down the event
itself -- or to stop strongly expressing
ourselves to assure the 'success' of the
event.
Throughout this process,
though, some activists are starting to think
about, and accept, bi and trans people and
issues.
What do you
think about the current widely used concept
of bisexuality?
In English-speaking
countries, the status of a woman -- as married
or not -- was actually an issue some time
ago. People always called her 'Miss' or
'Mrs.' I hope, and I am certain, that in
the future the dichotomy between 'same sex'
and 'opposite sex' will not be a problem
for people.
The concept and the
words 'bisexual', 'homosexual' and 'heterosexual'
should be obsolete, like 'Miss' or 'Mrs.'
The outer appearance of genitals may become
like being tall or short, black or white.
Please remember that cross-race sex and
marriage was illegal in some places in the
past.
My view is that the
binary gender system may change. As more
people understand that this artificial system
is socially constructed, we will become
more free from that system. More bisexuals,
transgenders and gender queers are coming
to the surface of society now, and this
might help change the gender system -- and
also our feelings about it.
Queer by choice? Yes,
we can choose our attitude toward the binary
gender system.
|