bimagazine an artistic project of the American Institute of Bisexuality AIB american institute of bisexuality
non fiction fiction poetry poetry visual arts music film theater
Inside BiMagazine  
Personal Story  
by James Withers, New York City, NY
Pornography Confession

First pornography confession: my first "pornography erection" was at a friend's birthday party. I was in fourth grade. He lived in a spacious house, and the kids were allowed to roam (he had brave parents!). I found his bedroom, a bedroom that had its own TV and a Playboy and Penthouse collection. I turned the TV on, jumped on the bed, and leafed through one magazine. One particular pictorial caught my attention, so much that if I had any sense I would have jacked off. A woman was standing in a washtub and being bathed by a man. She had long legs and brown skin, but what intrigued me was the couple. How did he get into the scene? Does he like bathing her? Does she like being bathed by him? The union of the two, completely different from the centerfold, held my interest so much that I stayed in my friend's bedroom for the whole party.

Second pornography confession: the first porn magazine I owned was stolen from a store. All the big kids were stealing from this store, so I figured I would give it a try. I do not even remember the name of the magazine (Cheri?), but there was a pictorial that made me spend many hours in my bedroom. She was a librarian. He was a student. No need to continue because you know the storyline, and if you don't, use your imagination. Once again, this particular pictorial moved me beyond anything else in the magazine, except for the erotic fiction. There was something about them, together, that I wanted to be a part of. I had to throw the magazine away because I was scared my parents would find it.

Last pornography confession: the first pornography video I bought was a bisexual compilation. I bought it because of the cover. There were three folk: a woman and two men. One of the men was in the middle, while the other two leaned on each of his arms. All three smiled into the camera, although the middle guy had a sexy smirk on his face. Before I ever watched the tape, I jerked off to the box cover.

What do these confessions add up to? Aside from an expansive pornographic history, they are the building blocks to (dare I use the word?) a sexuality that can be described as bisexual. There I said it. No hissing please! I get a bit anxious describing myself as bisexual because of all the baggage associated with the word. Some baggage that is unfair, and other baggage that is deserved because we bisexuals are bags of wind. The whole "I love people, not genitals" line is witty rhetoric, but has a smug smell to it. As if gender love is a big sin. Also bisexuals are bothersome. We use ugly words like "bi-phobia", complain constantly about having no safe places, cry over the disdain from gays and lesbians, cry over the disgust from straight folk, and assume we are the vanguard of some glorious revolution that will bring KY to every household (the sound you now hear is my bisexual card being ripped at the center). Maybe all of the above will happen when people define themselves only by sexuality, as if sexuality is some progressive force that is going to change the world. If being fucked by a woman with a strap-on, as my face is buried in some guy's (or woman's) hairy bush, would end world hunger I would do it in a minute -- I would even do it if it would not end world hunger -- but that personal act does not change the material world, a world that is simultaneously independent and authoritative. Sexuality, while fun, is not revolutionary and will not bring the walls of oppression down. The attempt to make bisexuality, or any sexuality for that matter, into the Holy Grail, or the cure for the common cold, is a fool's game.

If sexuality, or bisexuality, is so benign, then why write about it? Good question, and if I am bitter, or drunk, I say I write about it because my sex life is wretched. If I am neither bitter nor drunk, then I paraphrase a line from Bernard Malamud's The Tenants: I write about sexuality because I know so little about it. Claiming an identity as a sexual being is effortless, but what is not so effortless is looking at the history that created that claim. Am I bisexual because I watched pornography, or did my bisexual nature seek out pornography?

 

A complicated question. Maybe a question that does not have an explanation; however, as a starting point let's turn to British cultural critic Jonathan Dollimore's ideas as quoted in Marjorie Garber's Visa Versa:

I find if I look at a video of a man and a woman having sex, I very much identify with both positions. I also find that the identification with the woman doesn't correspond precisely with my gay experience where, for example, I might want to be fucked by that man as another man...I want to be fucked by that man as a woman -- my experience is very strongly with the woman -- my desire is going very strongly through the woman. To put it quite simply, there are times when I want the vagina. I'm not just wanting to position myself in the position of the woman as a man.

I am just jerking off when I look at a video, but there is something about Dollimore's words that illuminates. I very much identify with both positions. Maybe the doublings, or to be literary for a moment, double consciousness, of pornography appeals to my bisexuality. Pornography allows the sexual pleasure of men and women to be glimpsed, and that is what attracts me. Unlike Dollimore I have no desire for a vagina, but I do want to see the clitoris and penis be pleasured, and my early forays into porn satisfied that need. Of course this theory is tenuous because it would mean I am into straight porn, which I'm not. Granted, I stole Cheri magazine when I was younger, but so much straight porn seems focused on the "money shot" of the man. That's fine, which explains the attraction to gay porn, but if both men and women are going to be involved, the bisexual freak in me wants to see both partners having fun. Both partners as the center of attention.

Of course all of this speculation can be quickly explained by one word: perversity. Maybe I am just a pervert. Plain and simple. To be honest, that seems more likely. Just so you do not think my sex life is all about pornography (it is, but allow me to live in my illusions), here is a story that involves real people. In middle school, there was a girl named Susie I was madly in lust with. I lusted after Susie because she had stunning breasts. They were large, and stalked my dreams.

Unfortunately, Susie liked me only as a "friend", and decided to date Mark, a geeky guy who wore jeans jackets. Mark knew of my lusty thoughts concerning Susie, and would tell me about their escapades during a math class. Pretty progressive for a middle school kid if you think about it. Mark, either being sadistic or a perv, would allow to me read the letters he and Susie wrote to each other. These letters intensified my lust for Susie, but also turned Mark into an object of lust. Soon I was dreaming of both Mark and Susie, and would have gladly done anything for them both if only asked.

Unfortunately, or fortunately depending on your perspective, there are many Marks and Susies in my past, but the number of Marks and Susies does not add much to my sex life. While I may dream of stunning breasts and jeans jackets, I end up spending Friday evenings watching "Homicide" (alas no longer on the air except in reruns) and listening to Sonny Rollins. I am a pervert without the life of a pervert. If my early trips to pornography highlighted a bisexual nature, they also highlighted an unconscious acknowledgment that there would be a fissure between my desires and reality, an acceptance that life is ultimately about solitude no matter how much booty you get. If solitude is our lot, part of our "human condition" (for proof read Marquez's One Hundred Years of Solitude), then bisexuality does not obliterate that. Double desire does not imply removal of loneliness. Isn't that always the case? Or is this just justification for a pathetic sex life? Or is this the life of a bisexual?

 

James Withers lives and writes in New York City. Some of his work has appeared in "The Advocate," "The New York Post," and "The Gay and Lesbian Review."

His dog Billie is spoiled rotten.

 
 
Copyright © 2008 bimagazine.org  All Rights Reserved